Caniglia's A Mano

This place was a complete surprise and genuine pleasure! We had an unexpected evening off and I wanted to support a small business so we tried this place early on Friday evening. It is located in a strip mallnon the northeast corner of 72nd and 370, next to Great Clips. It was very clean, the food was great, and the service was super attentive and warm. The pizza crust was the true standout. Thin without being soggy or crunchy. Crisp and chewy! Perfect! The side salad was generous with iceberg, tomato, cucumber, olives and banana peppers. They even had a Balsamic vinagarette. The large sized pizza fed four hungry adults. The marinara was well balanced, tomato-y without tasting undercooked or overspiced. The Italian sausage was ground fine and didn't have an over powering anise flavor. The toppings were heaping and very typical of Omaha style pizza. The dining room was accessible with basically zero entry but did have two swinging doors. They have 4 large TVs but thankfully on mute and high enough not to be intrusive. The music was reasonable. They even have an outdoor space, bar seating and take out. We spent $48 on pizza, and soft drinks for four and two side salads. My dad and sons all said how much they liked it. All and all a very positive experience and would highly recommend! My only ticky tacky persnickety issue was that the ceiling fans were lower than the recessed lights so the dining room had a low grade strobe effect . Not a deal breaker but I noticed it.

What an absolute treat this place is and probably one of the best experiences I've had since I've been to San Diego. The owners were there and were more than happy to help us out and their charisma was just something you don't really see that much in the entire state of Nebraska. They had such a willingness to help, and their goal was to share an amazing experience as much as possible. They went over the menu with us and gave us tips and tricks from other customers and ultimately we settled on slice orders of The Alfredo, Tony's Favorite, The Veggie, Spicy BBQ Chicken, Pasta Salad, and Two pieces of Cheesy Bread. The cheesy bread came out and it looked fantastic, like it literally was rushed as soon as it came out of the oven, still molten and all. It came with a side of sauce as well which tasted great with it, but the bread itself seemed seasoned well enough that it didn't even really need it. We tried the cheesy bread in some of the pasta salad "sauce" and it was absolutely incredible. Just dip it in there, I'm sure you'll love it. When talking with the owners originally they described slices as a giant slice cut into two, which is exactly true. Two orders of slices as they stated comes down to about a half of a medium size pizza. Moving on, the pizza was absolutely incredible. Not too stiff of a crust, but not doughy either. A nice crisp/crunch to it and each bite was just absolutely fantastic. I was actually upset at myself that I didn't order more, but they were topped perfectly. When I say perfectly too, the Tony's favorite was just magical. To the point that I blanked out because my mind short circuited with the perfect flow of flavor. It wasn't just one flavor that was overwhelming, it was absolutely everything working together and I don't think I can describe it in better words than that. Get a slice of it, and just take a big bite into it and chew. In the end, this is the kind of place that I wish I could somehow yell at Dave Portnoy and others just so they got the chance to try it out. We don't live close to it at all but if people were to ask us "Do you know where to go to get the best pizza in Omaha?" then there's no doubt in my mind I'll absolutely tell them here.

My family and I ate here for the first time last night and we had a good experience. We each had a house salad and while it was okay, I felt like the ingredients could have been fresher. I definitely appreciate housemade salad dressings though. We all enjoyed our pizza slices and the cheesy bread. And I was really that they serve Pepsi products! Service was good. I'm sure we'll be back in the future.

The name Caniglia’s is synonymous with good food. Caniglia’s pizza and pub is right up there We had a half meat, lovers and half vegetarian pizza. The crust was nice and crisp. We had side salads also and they were very fresh. The service was outstanding. The owner himself waited on us, and it was very enjoyable to talk with him. I would recommend this hands-down and plan to eat there again next time we’re in Omaha.

Oh my gosh. My new pizza favorite! Pictured is Tony's favorite. V good portion, great flavor! Wife had basic hamburger pizza, enjoyed it. With 1 Italian draft and soda, $21.50. Very reasonable! It was so good! Jordan, manager/owner very hospitable! Been back several times, great menu. Off 72nd and highway 370. 11425 South 72nd Street. Across from Russell's Carwash.

This was our 2nd visit. The pizza is great. The buffalo chicken sub was also great - one of the things I dislike about subs is TOO MUCH BREAD - but the bread on this was just right. The chicken has a nice grilled taste (and is in chunks so easier to eat!) and I was able to get the sauces on the side so I could adjust the heat level. The pasta salad is made in house and has a slightly sweet dressing. I loved it. The servers are attentive, making sure we got our refills right away.

Heard about this place and thought we would give it a try. We were not disappointed! Tony and his crew put out an outstanding pizza! We had a Large Tony's Favorite and our friends ordered a medium Hamburger Onion. We started with Italian Nachos which were delicious, served with whole wheat tortillas. Staff were super friendly and attentive! Pizza toppings were abundant, fresh and tasty! Crust was on the thin side and crispy! I will make a special trip back to try their Sausage and Peppers! You have to try this place, you won't be disappointed!